WalletHub, Financial Company
@WalletHub
The cheapest full coverage insurance for bad drivers is from Geico and Progressive, which provide up to 40% in savings compared to other high-risk policies. For drivers with most types of moving violations on their record, including speeding and reckless driving, Geico is the best option. Progressive provides the best rates for drivers with more serious infractions such as at-fault accidents and DUI.
In addition to the savings they offer bad drivers, both Geico and Progressive extend coverage to drivers whose states have required them to submit an SR-22 or FR-44. These are documents that serve as proof of insurance for individuals with severe infractions on their driving records, and many insurance companies will not offer coverage to drivers who need them.
How Bad Driving Affects the Price of Full Coverage
Having multiple infractions from the last 3-5 years on your driving record classifies you as “high-risk,” which means you’re more likely to get into an accident or file a claim than the average driver.
Even though bad drivers pay more for full coverage auto insurance, the exact amount varies depending on factors such as the seriousness of any previous infractions. For example, a speeding ticket will only increase your rate by about 25%, while a DUI causes it to go up by 80% on average.
Cost of Insurance for Bad Drivers, by Violation
Violation |
Average Premium |
Percent Increase |
None |
$844 |
N/A |
Speeding |
$1,153 |
36.6% |
Red Light Infraction |
$1,153 |
36.6% |
1 At-Fault Accident |
$1,429 |
69.3% |
Open Container |
$1,471 |
74.3% |
Suspended License |
$1,751 |
107.6% |
Reckless Driving |
$2,005 |
137.6% |
DUI |
$2,056 |
143.6% |
Note: Quotes based on average rates from the largest insurance companies in California.
Full Coverage Options for High-Risk Drivers
If your bad driving record is preventing you from finding a full coverage auto insurance policy that fits your budget, you have a few options. Depending on your driving record, you might want to consider getting coverage from a company that specializes in nonstandard insurance, like The General or Dairyland. If you’re still unable to find an insurer that will cover you, then you should consider entering your state’s assigned-risk pool.
While most assigned-risk programs will only allow you to get the minimum coverage required by state law, it’s a good temporary option while you work toward improving your driving record.
Most insurance companies only take the past two to three years into consideration when calculating your premium, so if you practice good habits on the road for long enough, you’ll eventually be able to get a better deal. Long-term, you should look for a company that gives strong discounts for good driving, like State Farm.
People also ask
Did we answer your question?