Is comprehensive insurance required?

Comprehensive insurance is worth it if the premium is a small percentage of the car’s value. Comprehensive insurance might also be worth it if the policyholder cannot afford to replace the vehicle without comprehensive coverage, or if the car is driven or parked in a particularly risky area.

Although comprehensive insurance is not mandatory in any state, dealerships and lenders frequently require comprehensive insurance, along with ... read full answercollision coverage, on leased or financed cars. In that case, comprehensive insurance is definitely worth it, because failing to meet the lender’s or lessor’s requirements could result in expensive force-placed insurance or even repossession.

Factors to Consider When Deciding If Comprehensive Insurance Is Worth It

• Your car’s age, mileage, and value.
• The cost of comprehensive insurance premiums.
• The risk of theft, vandalism, and natural disasters in your area.
• Your ability to pay for repairs or a replacement vehicle out of pocket.

An old rule of thumb recommended dropping comprehensive coverage when a car was five to six years old or had 100,000 miles. But this rule is now outdated, since newer cars have increased longevity alongside higher repair costs. Now, the standard rule is that comprehensive and collision coverage are both worth buying if the combined premium is less than 10% of the car’s value, minus the deductible.

Cost is only one factor, however, so you should also consider how likely you are to file a claim, as well as what would happen to you financially if your car was stolen or destroyed by something other than an accident and you didn’t have coverage. For instance, if theft, animal collisions, or natural disasters are particularly common in your area, you are especially likely to need comprehensive insurance. Similarly, even if your comprehensive premium is 15% of your car’s value, for example, comprehensive insurance might still be worth it if you rely on the car and can’t afford to replace it yourself.

You should drop comprehensive insurance when you can afford to repair or replace your car out of pocket in a worst-case scenario. You should not drop comprehensive insurance if the car is valuable, since the coverage is inexpensive and will usually pay up to the car’s actual cash value, minus a deductible. Additionally, you definitely should not drop comprehensive coverage if it’s required by your lender or lessor. Doing so can result in serious ... read full answerconsequences like force-placed insurance and even repossession.

Comprehensive insurance is sometimes considered “bad luck” insurance, since it covers things that are mostly out of your control as a driver, like vandalism, theft, natural disasters or hitting a deer. A standard rule of thumb is to drop collision and comprehensive insurance when the combined premiums are more than 10% of your car’s value, minus your deductible.

However, you should only consider this guideline within the context of your personal circumstances. It’s also worth noting that many experts consider comprehensive insurance to be a better investment than collision coverage, since it is not affected by your driving habits and is generally cheaper.

In addition to your car’s value and your own finances, how likely you are to file a claim should factor into whether or not you drop comprehensive car insurance coverage. For example, even if you could comfortably replace your car, it probably isn’t smart to drop comprehensive insurance if you live in an area with frequent hurricanes.