2025's Best Insurance Agents in Fort Myers, FL

Please find below 2025's best insurance agents in Fort Myers, FL. Use the filters to refine or expand your insurance agent search.

Updating Insurance Agents

Michelle Accola

GreatFlorida Insurance Holding Corporation

5 out of 5 rating48 Reviews

Michelle Accola is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by GreatFlorida Insurance, and is based out of Fort Myers, FL. She maintains active appointments with multiple insurance companies, including: American... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Flood‚ Health‚ Home‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters‚ Umbrella

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

12401 Commerce Lakes Dr Suite 4, Fort Myers, FL 33913

Call 239-237-1550

Website

Profile

Tanya Grubii

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating13 Reviews

Tanya Grubii is licensed as an insurance broker, employed by State Farm, and is based out of Naples, FL. She maintains active appointments with the following insurance companies: State Farm... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

7765 Preserve Lane Suite 5, Naples, FL 34119

Call 239-631-5601

Website

Profile

Carlos A Miranda

5 out of 5 rating1 Review

Carlos Miranda is an insurance agent operating out of Fort Myers, FL.

13651 Parkcrest Blvd Apt 321, Fort Myers, FL 33912

Call 239-368-7492

Profile

Lynn Marie Tiscione

5 out of 5 rating1 Review

Lynn Tiscione is an insurance agent operating out of Fort Myers, FL.

Policies: Annuities‚ Health‚ Life

12995 S Cleveland Ave Ste 50, Fort Myers, FL 33907

Call 239-689-4206

Profile

Courtney Rae Rogers

5 out of 5 rating1 Review

Courtney Rogers is an insurance agent operating out of Estero, FL.

Policies: Annuities‚ Health‚ Life

20048 Heatherstone Way Unit 3, Estero, FL 33928

Call 239-839-2863

Profile

Joel Hinman

State Farm

4.9 out of 5 rating861 Reviews

I am your State Farm Insurance Agent for the Fort Myers, FL area. I have been a State Farm Agent since 2017. My team and I enjoy assisting with resident... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

14651 Palm Beach Blvd, Suite 103, Fort Myers, FL 33905

Call 239-313-5011

Website

Profile

Charles Roy Harrod JR

Farmers Insurance

4.9 out of 5 rating458 Reviews

As your local Farmers agent in Fort Myers, Florida, I help customers like you identify the insurance coverage that best fits your needs. This process is straightforward and personalized to... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters‚ Umbrella

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

13130 Westlinks Ter Ste 3, Fort Myers, FL 33913

Call 239-766-7585

Website

Profile

Mary Dixon

State Farm

4.9 out of 5 rating163 Reviews

Mary Dixon is a second generation State Farm Agent who is passionate about helping family, friends, and her community. She maintains active appointments with State Farm Insurance Company and Citizens... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

12713 McGregor Blvd Suite 1, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Call 239-267-2828

Website

Profile

Ashley Duckett

We Insure

4.9 out of 5 rating97 Reviews

Ashley Duckett is an experienced insurance professional with an emphasis to go above and beyond for her clients. Ashley’s goal for exceptional customer service and educating her clients has made... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Flood‚ Home‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

13031 McGregor Blvd Suite 5, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Call 239-201-7064

Website

Profile

Buzz Hill

State Farm

4.9 out of 5 rating45 Reviews

Buzz Hill is licensed as an insurance broker, employed by State Farm, and is based out of Naples, FL. He maintains active appointments with the following insurance companies: State Farm... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

4522 Executive Drive Suite102, Naples, FL 34119

Call 239-594-1717

Website

Profile

Cathy L. Sink

Allstate

4.8 out of 5 rating610 Reviews

Fort Myers insurance agent Cathy Sink can help you protect the things that are important, your family, home, car, boat and more. Get a quote now to see if you... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

13111 Paul J Doherty Parkway, Unit 110, Fort Myers, FL 33913

Call 239-561-8600

Website

Profile

Michele Losapio

State Farm

4.8 out of 5 rating195 Reviews

As your State Farm Agent for the Fort Myers and Lehigh Acres area, I make it my goal to treat you as family. As a Florida native I understand the... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

9321 Ben C Pratt/6 Mile Cypress Pwy, Suite 120, Fort Myers, FL 33966

Call 239-332-4999

Website

Profile

Nick Glaeser

State Farm

4.8 out of 5 rating157 Reviews

I am a second generation State Farm agent in the Fort Myers, FL area. My team has over 45 years of combined State Farm team experience. I am a graduate... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

6700 Daniels Pkwy, Suite 2, Fort Myers, FL 33912

Call 239-334-6050

Website

Profile

Belinda Malolli

Allstate

4.8 out of 5 rating66 Reviews

I have been an Allstate Agent in Naples, Florida since 2002. At my agency, we like to make each other laugh and we can always count on my husband, who... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

1855 Veterans Park Dr, Naples, FL 34109

Call 239-593-4433

Website

Profile

Mike Arcentales

Allstate

4.7 out of 5 rating188 Reviews

As an Insurance Professional in Southwest Florida, I am proud to call Allstate my company. With over 29 years in the insurance and financial services industry, my knowledge and experience... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

27241 Bay Landing Dr, Bonita Springs, FL 34135

Call 239-947-4333

Website

Profile

Peter Look

GreatFlorida Insurance Holding Corporation

4.7 out of 5 rating160 Reviews

Peter Look is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by GreatFlorida Insurance, and is based out of Cape Coral, FL. He maintains active appointments with multiple insurance companies, including: ACE... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Flood‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters‚ Umbrella

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

2125 Santa Barbara Blvd Suite 2, Cape Coral, FL 33991

Call 239-945-2886

Website

Profile

Dawn Sullivan

State Farm

4.7 out of 5 rating152 Reviews

Dawn Sullivan was born and raised in Utica, NY, but her heart is right here in Southwest Florida. A graduate from The State University of New York, Dawn joined the... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

2708 Santa Barbara Blvd, Suite 120, Cape Coral, FL 33914

Call 239-541-3276

Website

Profile

Joan Wolbach

State Farm

4.6 out of 5 rating192 Reviews

Joan Schlereth is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by State Farm, and is based out of North Fort Myers, FL. She maintains active appointments with the following insurance companies:... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

15201 N Cleveland Ave #606 Merchant's Crossing Plaza, North Fort Myers, FL 33903

Call 239-731-5626

Website

Profile

Tim Collier

State Farm

4.6 out of 5 rating171 Reviews

I am your State Farm Insurance Agent for the Cape Coral, FL area and I have been a State Farm Agent since 2007. I am a second generation State Farm... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

1315 SE 47th Street, Cape Coral, FL 33904

Call 239-541-4444

Website

Profile

Fred Trelli

GEICO

4.5 out of 5 rating484 Reviews

Hi, I'm Fred Trelli, and I have been your GEICO Insurance Agent since 2005, serving Lee, Collier, and Charlotte counties. I have over 22 years' experience as an insurance agent,... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ ID Theft‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters‚ Umbrella

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

12123 South Cleveland Avenue, Fort Myers, FL 33907

Call 239-415-7777

Website

Profile

Jill Wedeles

Allstate

4.5 out of 5 rating48 Reviews

Jill Wedeles is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by Allstate, and is based out of Fort Myers, FL. She maintains active appointments with multiple insurance companies, including: Allstate Insurance... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

8841 College Pkwy, Ste 103, Fort Myers, FL 33919

Call 239-482-7804

Website

Profile

John Hanson Ridall

Test Company 1

4.5 out of 5 rating2 Reviews

John Ridall is an insurance agent employed by Test Company 1, operating out of their Ftmyers, FL office.

Policies: Health‚ Life

4707junoniact, Fort Myers, FL 33908

Call 239-481-3310

Website

Profile

Laura Brauch

State Farm

4.3 out of 5 rating73 Reviews

I've been honored to serve the community of Lehigh Acres and Southwest Florida as a State Farm Agent since 1999. Building relationships in the community and with our policyholders, while... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Flood‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

3509 Lee Blvd, Suite 1, Lehigh Acres, FL 33971

Call 239-303-1700

Website

Profile

Tonya Edison

State Farm

4.3 out of 5 rating62 Reviews

Tonya Edison is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by State Farm, and is based out of North Fort Myers, FL. She maintains active appointments with the following insurance companies:... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

3443 Hancock Bridge Parkway Unit 401, North Fort Myers, FL 33903

Call 239-652-1006

Website

Profile

Robert Estling

Allstate

4.3 out of 5 rating12 Reviews

Robert Estling is licensed as an insurance broker, employed by Allstate Insurance, and is based out of Naples, FL. He maintains active appointments with the following insurance companies: Allstate Insurance,... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Long-term Care‚ Motorcycle‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

12820 Tamiami Trail N #3, Naples, FL 34110

Call 239-594-9567

Website

Profile

Craig M Arndt

Allstate

4.2 out of 5 rating91 Reviews

Craig Arndt is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by Allstate, and is based out of Lutz, FL. He maintains active appointments with several insurance companies: Allstate, Pacific Life Insurance... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent near Fort Myers, FL

820 Lafayette St, Cape Coral, FL 33904

Call 813-964-0608

Website

Profile

Larry Snider

State Farm

4.2 out of 5 rating57 Reviews

Larry Snider is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by State Farm, and is based out of Fort Myers, FL. He maintains active appointments with the following insurance companies: State... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

12995 S. Cleveland Ave Suite 103B, Fort Myers, FL 33907

Call 239-561-8599

Website

Profile

Jeremy Henley

Allstate

4.2 out of 5 rating26 Reviews

Jeremy Henley is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by Allstate, and is based out of Fort Myers, FL. He maintains active appointments with multiple insurance companies, including: Allstate Insurance... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters

2025's Best Insurance Agent in Fort Myers, FL

15245 S Tamiami Trail, Ste 11, Fort Myers, FL 33908

Call 239-433-3117

Website

Profile

Page 1 of 25Next

Questions & Answers

Comparing insurance agents can be tough. But you've got the knowledgeable WalletHub community on your side. Other consumers have a wealth of knowledge to share, and we encourage everyone to do so while respecting our content guidelines. Please keep in mind that editorial and user-generated content on this page is not reviewed or otherwise endorsed by any financial institution. In addition, it is not the financial institution's responsibility to ensure all posts and questions are answered.

Best Insurance Agents in Nearby Cities

Insurance Companies in Palm Coast

Insurance Companies in Boca Raton

Insurance Companies in Hollywood

Insurance Companies in Clearwater

Insurance Companies in West Palm Beach

Insurance Companies > Florida > Fort Myers

Important Disclosures

Ad Disclosure: Certain offers, companies or professionals (collectively “listings”) that appear on this site, originate from paying advertisers. For full transparency, here is a list of our current advertisers.

Advertisers compensate WalletHub when you click on a link, or your application is approved, or your account is opened. Advertising impacts how and where listings appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear and their prevalence). At WalletHub we try to present a wide array of offers, companies and professionals, but our listings do not represent all financial services companies or products.

Advertising enables WalletHub to provide you proprietary tools, services, and content at no charge. Advertising does not impact WalletHub's editorial content including our best picks, reviews, ratings and opinions. Those are completely independent and not provided, commissioned, or endorsed by any issuer, as our editors follow a strict editorial policy.

WalletHub is not a financial advisor. Our goal is to provide you with top-notch content, data, and tools. You are responsible for deciding what financial products and providers are best for your needs.

We work hard to show you up-to-date product terms, however, this information does not originate from us and thus, we do not guarantee its accuracy. Actual terms may vary. Before submitting an application, always verify all terms and conditions with the offering institution. Please let us know if you notice any differences.