2026's Best Insurance Agents in New York, NY

Please find below 2026's best insurance agents in New York, NY. Use the filters to refine or expand your insurance agent search.

Updating Insurance Agents

Steve Fay

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating2,383 Reviews

For almost 10 years, Steve Fay State Farm Insurance Agency Inc has been offering most forms of insurance and financial services. Our licensed, multilingual and highly experienced team members that... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Pet‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

6608 18th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11204

Call 718-676-4900

Website

Profile

Hielly Martinez

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating2,120 Reviews

I earned the privilege of being a State Farm Agent in October of 2008. I say “earned” because a State Farm Agency is not business you can simply buy, it’s... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Credit‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

251 E 138th street, Bronx, NY 10451

Call 347-271-4444

Website

Profile

Jose Rivera

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating1,583 Reviews

Our State Farm Agency has been open since November 2018! Agent Jose Rivera has 8 years of State Farm Insurance experience. Our agency offers free insurance and financial reviews in... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

169-22 Jamaica Avenue, Jamaica, NY 11432

Call 347-644-5333

Website

Profile

Christine Relyea - State Farm Insurance Agent

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating1,212 Reviews

My name is Christine Relyea a local State Farm agent located in Staten Island, New York. I grew up in Upstate NY. I started my Agency in 2003, i love... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

2391 Richmond Avenue, Staten Island, NY 10314

Call 718-698-5803

Website

Profile

Ariel Abreu

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating908 Reviews

I earned the privilege of becoming a State Farm Agent December 2020. I say "earned" because a State Farm Agency is not a business you can simply buy, it's a... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Renters

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

1427 College Point Blvd, College Point, NY 11356

Call 718-799-0221

Website

Profile

Chris Moretti

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating822 Reviews

I find great pleasure in helping people and so does my team! By providing proper insurance and financial services to my customers, I’ve had the privilege of experiencing the joys... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

22218 Union Tpke, Oakland Gardens, NY 11364

Call 718-468-1200

Website

Profile

Chandy Frias Vargas

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating715 Reviews

Chandy Frias Vargas is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by State Farm, and is based out of Brooklyn, NY. She maintains active appointments with State Farm and American Pet... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

7015 Fort Hamilton Parkway , Brooklyn, NY 11228

Call 347-462-0079

Website

Profile

Michael Fay

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating672 Reviews

Hello and welcome to the Michael Fay State Farm Agency! At Michael Fay State Farm Insurance Agency our licensed, multilingual and highly experienced team members are here to serve you... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

16407 Northern Blvd, Flushing, NY 11358

Call 929-553-2331

Website

Profile

Traci Menes

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating649 Reviews

The Traci Menes State Farm Insurance Agency is proud to serve customers in NY, CT, NJ and PA with Insurance and Financial Services. My team of licensed professionals and I... show more

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

4734 White Plains Rd, Bronx, NY 10470

Call 718-325-0100

Website

Profile

A.J. Ciccone

Allstate

5 out of 5 rating643 Reviews

As an Allstate agent, I feel it is my responsibility to help the customers with their options, and what fits their needs. It’s important to be there for life’s moments... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

684 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Call 718-412-9192

Website

Profile

Robert L. Stevenson II

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating534 Reviews

I started with State Farm back in 1992 as an intern in the Minority internship program. After graduating I started as a full time employee for the company. I did... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Pet‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent in New York, NY

850 7th Avenue, Suite 1005, New York, NY 10019

Call 212-397-0580

Website

Profile

Jari Santiago

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating514 Reviews

Jari Santiago is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by State Farm, and is based out of New York, NY. The Jari Santiago State Farm office opened in 2014 to... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Pet‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent in New York, NY

4869 Broadway, New York, NY 10034

Call 646-478-8484

Website

Profile

Amber Chow

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating412 Reviews

I am a proud, long-time resident of the Flushing, Queens and NYC community. I have dedicated my professional career to educating my community, serving my neighbors and building lasting relationships... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

5904 A Main Street, Flushing, NY 11355

Call 718-886-5556

Website

Profile

Steve Candon

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating231 Reviews

Steve Candon is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by State Farm, and is based out of Franklin Square, NY. He maintains active appointments with State Farm.

Policies: Annuities‚ Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Disability‚ Flood‚ Health‚ Home‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Pet‚ Renters‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

932 Hempstead Turnpike, Franklin Square, NY 11010

Call 516-488-3333

Website

Profile

Nicole Namy

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating146 Reviews

My name is Nicole Namy, but I prefer Nikki! I am a third generation State Farm Agent. My agency is located at 3064 Boston Road, Bronx, NY. We proudly service... show more

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

3064 Boston Road, Bronx, NY 10469

Call 347-899-8004

Website

Profile

Ralph Palmiotto

Allstate

5 out of 5 rating25 Reviews

Ralph Palmiotto is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by Allstate, and is based out of Whitestone, NY. He maintains active appointments with Allstate.

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters‚ Travel

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

16606 24th Rd, Whitestone, NY 11357

Call 718-352-8080

Website

Profile

JW Lee

State Farm

5 out of 5 rating17 Reviews

JW Lee is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by State Farm, and is based out of Little Neck, NY. He maintains active appointments with State Farm Insurance.

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

24207 Northern Blvd, Little Neck, NY 11362

Call 718-971-0224

Website

Profile

Zachary Ordynans

Farmers Insurance

5 out of 5 rating12 Reviews

As your local Farmers agent, I understand that Manhattan is a special place with insurance needs that are different than just about anywhere else. I help customers meet complicated insurance... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Pet‚ Renters‚ Umbrella

2026's Best Insurance Agent in New York, NY

145 W 72nd St Fl 2, New York, NY 10023

Call 212-595-5590

Website

Profile

Louis Peters

AMP Insurance Brokerage

5 out of 5 rating9 Reviews

Louis Peters is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by AMP Insurance Brokerage LLC, and is based out of Brooklyn, NY.
He maintains active appointments with the following insurance companies:... show more

Policies: Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Flood‚ Health‚ Home‚ ID Theft‚ Legal Insurance‚ Life‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Umbrella

7709 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11209

Call 212-518-6317

Website

Profile

David J. Louie Sr.

David J. Louie Inc.

5 out of 5 rating9 Reviews

David J. Louie Sr. began his career at an accounting firm in Chinatown where he was exposed to the growing needs for insurance professionals in the Asian market niche.... show more

Policies: Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Credit‚ Flood‚ Health‚ Home‚ ID Theft‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

217 Park Row 2 Floor, New York, NY 10038

Call 212-941-8919

Website

Profile

Michael Majorino

V.A.C Insurance Agency

5 out of 5 rating7 Reviews

Michael Majorino is a licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Broker and Owner of V.A.C Insurance Agency. Michael’s ability to determine clients’ particular needs and financial situations is what makes VAC... show more

Policies: Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Flood‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

9712 3rd Avenue, 1st Floor , Brooklyn, NY 11209

Call 718-338-3400

Website

Profile

Kevin Kautzmann

Executive Benefits of New York (EBNY)

5 out of 5 rating5 Reviews

Kevin Kautzmann is the Principal and Founder of EBNY Financial, LLC. Since founding EBNY in 1998, Kevin has provided his clients with objective, exemplary service. Kevin prides himself on his... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Commercial Property‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Life‚ Long-term Care‚ Professional Liability‚ Title‚ Workers Compensation

80 Fifth Avenue, Suite 1403, New York, NY 10011

Call 212-269-2625

Website

Profile

Martin Ridgers

Farmers Insurance

5 out of 5 rating2 Reviews

Long Island City, Queens residents and businesses we are here for you as with have been for the past five years. We will listen to your needs and provide you... show more

Policies: Business‚ Car‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Umbrella

11-42 46th Rd, Long Island City, NY 11101

Call 347-778-5891

Website

Profile

Ethan Kosmin

Ek Insurance Agency Llc

5 out of 5 rating1 Review

Ethan Kosmin is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by Ek Insurance Agency Llc, and is based out of New York, NY. He maintains active appointments with multiple... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Cyber Risk‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

99 Wall St #1234, New York, NY 10005

Call 484-800-1000

Website

Profile

Michael Honig

Honig Conte Porrino Insurance Agency

5 out of 5 rating1 Review

Michael Honig is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by Honig Conte Porrino Insurance Agency, and is based out of Brooklyn, NY.
He maintains active appointments with the following insurance... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Cyber Risk‚ Flood‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Personal Articles‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

129 W 27th St, 6th Floor, New York, NY 10001

Call 212-777-7113

Website

Profile

F. Michael Conte

Honig Conte Porrino Insurance Agency

5 out of 5 rating1 Review

F. Michael Conte is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by the Honig Conte Porrino Insurance Agency, and is based out of New York City, NY. Conte spends a lot... show more

Policies: Business‚ Disability‚ Flood‚ Home‚ Life‚ Long-term Care‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters

129 W 27th St, New York, NY 10001

Call 212-777-7113

Website

Profile

Zachary Brody

Lumiere Financial Group

5 out of 5 rating1 Review

Ever since I was a kid, I wanted to make people feel safe, which is what led me to start my own security alarm company in high school. Later on,... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Life‚ Long-term Care

1270 Avenue Of The Americas, 10th Floor Ste 1000, New York, NY 10020

Call 212-817-3885

Website

Profile

Melissa Matassa

GEICO

4.9 out of 5 rating1,519 Reviews

Melissa Matassa is licensed as an insurance agent, employed by GEICO, and is based out of Lynbrook, NY. She maintains active appointments with GEICO, American Bankers Insurance Company Of Florida,... show more

Policies: Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Flood‚ Health‚ Home‚ ID Theft‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Pet‚ Professional Liability‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Umbrella‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

475 Sunrise Hwy, Lynbrook, NY 11563

Call 516-881-3210

Website

Profile

Jewelz Santiago

State Farm

4.9 out of 5 rating1,188 Reviews

I am a firm believer that kindness flourishes the soul. I have been in the insurance industry for a little over 16 years proudly representing State Farm. My agency is... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Boat‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Credit‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Pet‚ Renters‚ Travel‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent in New York, NY

3657 Broadway Frnt 2, New York, NY 10031

Call 646-524-7484

Website

Profile

Emond Richardson

State Farm

4.9 out of 5 rating1,143 Reviews

The Emond Richardson State Farm Agency’s professionally trained team members are here to serve you for all your insurance and financial needs. Emond and the team have been serving New... show more

Policies: Annuities‚ Business‚ Car‚ Commercial Auto‚ Commercial Property‚ Disability‚ Health‚ Home‚ Life‚ Motorcycle‚ Personal Articles‚ Renters‚ Workers Compensation

2026's Best Insurance Agent near New York, NY

2201 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229

Call 718-975-3420

Website

Profile

Page 1 of 25Next

Questions & Answers

Comparing insurance agents can be tough. But you've got the knowledgeable WalletHub community on your side. Other consumers have a wealth of knowledge to share, and we encourage everyone to do so while respecting our content guidelines. Please keep in mind that editorial and user-generated content on this page is not reviewed or otherwise endorsed by any financial institution. In addition, it is not the financial institution's responsibility to ensure all posts and questions are answered.

Best Insurance Agents in Nearby Cities

Insurance Companies in Buffalo

Insurance Companies in Rochester

Insurance Companies in Yonkers

Insurance Companies in Syracuse

Insurance Companies in Albany

Insurance Companies > New York > New York

Important Disclosures

Ad Disclosure: Certain offers, companies or professionals (collectively “listings”) that appear on this site, originate from paying advertisers. For full transparency, here is a list of our current advertisers.

Advertisers compensate WalletHub when you click on a link, or your application is approved, or your account is opened. Advertising impacts how and where listings appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear and their prevalence). At WalletHub we try to present a wide array of offers, companies and professionals, but our listings do not represent all financial services companies or products.

Advertising enables WalletHub to provide you proprietary tools, services, and content at no charge. Advertising does not impact WalletHub's editorial content including our best picks, reviews, ratings and opinions. Those are completely independent and not provided, commissioned, or endorsed by any issuer, as our editors follow a strict editorial policy.

WalletHub is not a financial advisor. Our goal is to provide you with top-notch content, data, and tools. You are responsible for deciding what financial products and providers are best for your needs.

We work hard to show you up-to-date product terms, however, this information does not originate from us and thus, we do not guarantee its accuracy. Actual terms may vary. Before submitting an application, always verify all terms and conditions with the offering institution. Please let us know if you notice any differences.