Currency Exchange Study: How to Save on International Spending
Converting U.S. dollars into a foreign currency is necessary for most trips abroad. And we generally have two options for doing so: 1) automatically with a credit card and 2) by converting hard currency at a bank or airport kiosk. But which is the better deal?
You may not think this is worth worrying about, but there are actually hundreds of dollars at stake for most international travelers. So a strategic approach to currency exchange could be the difference between flying first class or coach, for example.
To help international travelers save as much as possible, WalletHub priced out the most popular currency exchange services. We collected the exchange rates and fees charged by the largest banks, credit unions and card networks as well as Travelex, which is commonly found in airports. And we determined how many Euros a traveler would get from each service in return for $300, as of May 12, 2017. We chose the Euro because it is the most popular currency among Americans traveling abroad.
You can find the results below, followed by a breakdown of the best international credit cards and bank accounts.
Cheapest Option: A no-foreign-transaction-fee credit card saves travelers 8.86% relative to Travelex and 6.77% compared to the average bank/credit union.
*Numbers are averages and use of a no-foreign-fee card is assumed.
Lack of Consumer Awareness: Banks and credit unions don’t appear interested in reducing their markups, which are still below Travelex’s costs.
*Note: 2014 was the first year that Credit Union data was collected.
Bank vs. Credit Union: Surprisingly, you won’t save money converting currency at a credit union rather than a bank.
Best Banks/Credit Unions: Even the cheapest banks and credit unions (State Employees CU, Comerica and Northern Trust) are more expensive than credit and debit cards.
|Top 3||Bank/Credit Union||% Higher Than Credit Card / Debit Card||Bottom 3||Bank/Credit Union||% Higher Than Credit Card / Debit Card|
|1||State Employees Credit Union||2.94%||33||ESL Federal Credit Union||9.96%|
|2||Comerica||3.55%||34||First Tech Federal Credit Union||10.29%|
|3||Northern Trust||3.85%||35||RBS Citizens||11.55%|
WalletHub’s editors selected the following accounts because they lack foreign transaction fees and excel in at least one other major category, such as rewards, fees or 0% intro APRs.
2017’s Best International Credit Cards
|Best for..||Card Name|
Barclaycard Arrival Plus® World Elite Mastercard®
|No Annual Fee||
Capital One® Quicksilver® Cash Rewards Credit Card
HSBC Platinum Mastercard® credit card
Bank of America® Travel Rewards credit card for Students
Capital One® Spark® Cash for Business
2017’s Best International Checking Accounts
|Best for..||Account Name|
Charles Schwab High Yield Investor Checking
Capital One 360 Checking Account
1. Use a credit card with no foreign transaction fee
Why waste the time exchanging physical currency, not to mention risk carrying it around, when a credit card will handle everything automatically and give you the best exchange rates? Plus, plastic provides a $0 liability guarantee for unauthorized transactions should your card be lost or stolen.
You’ll save money no matter what card you use, but a credit card with no foreign fees will reduce your costs even more. Just remember to get such a card before booking anything through a foreign-based company. If the transaction is processed outside of the U.S., it will trigger a foreign fee.
2. Bring a debit card with low international ATM withdrawal fees as well
You’re going to need cash at some point, whether it’s for a cab, tipping a bellboy or something else entirely. Bringing a low-cost Visa or Mastercard debit card will enable you to get cash as needed and enjoy plastic’s favorable exchange rate. Unlike cash, a card is also replaceable if you get pickpocketed.
3. Notify your bank of your travel plans
Most credit and debit card companies will freeze your account if international purchases begin appearing without warning. That can be a clear sign of fraud, after all.
In fact, American Express and Capital One are the only major credit card issuers that automatically detect when you’re traveling, according to WalletHub’s latest International Credit Card Report.
So make sure to tell your card issuers when you’re leaving, where you’re going and when you’ll be back.
4. Get the phone number to call your bank collect
If your card gets lost or stolen, being able to contact your bank will be helpful for two reasons. First, you’ll be able to nip any potential fraud in the bud. Second, you may be able to convince your bank to send you a replacement card.
Only three major credit card issuers will do so for free, according to WalletHub’s research, but a handful of others offer the service for a small fee. In any case, remember to be persistent. Even if international replacement cards aren’t standard, they’re usually available to customers in need who push the issue.
5. Steer clear of dynamic currency conversion
If a merchant offers to convert your purchase total from the local currency to U.S. dollars, don’t accept. They might be trying to help you, sure. Or they could be looking for an excuse to apply a high exchange rate and squeeze a bit more money out of you.
It’s best not to find out, especially when you can use your phone or a small pocket calculator to make quick conversions and see how much things cost.
|2017 Exchange Rate||2017 Fee||% Higher Than Best Option|
|Credit Union Avg.||1.1579||$2.70||4.93%|
* Location New York City’s John F. Kennedy Airport
|Bank||2017 Exchange Rate||2017 Fee**||% Higher Than Credit Card / Debit Card*|
|First Republic Bank||$1.1363||$0.0||4.12%|
|BMO Harris Bank||$1.1368||$0.0||4.16%|
|Bank of America||$1.1482||$0.0||5.11%|
|Bank of the West||$1.1483||$5.0||6.70%|
|Fifth Third Bank||$1.1750||$0.0||7.27%|
|State Employees Credit Union||$1.1226||$0.0||2.94%|
|Redstone Federal Credit Union||$1.1309||$2.0||4.30%|
|Bank Fund Staff Federal Credit Union||$1.1400||$0.0||4.43%|
|United Nations Federal Credit Union||$1.1558||$0.0||5.73%|
|Onpoint Community Credit Union***||$1.1634||$0.0||6.35%|
|Visions Federal Credit Union||$1.1815||$0.0||7.78%|
|Citizens Equity First Credit Union||$1.1562||$10.0||8.91%|
|ESL Federal Credit Union||$1.2101||$0.0||9.96%|
|First Tech Federal Credit Union||$1.1538||$15.0||10.29%|
** Fee collected for in-person exchange.
***$10 is waived when $300 or more is exchanged.
We contacted 45 of the 50 largest credit unions, and only 10 offer currency exchange services.
On May 12, 2017, we called branch locations for 70 of the largest banks and credit unions as well as the Travelex location in New York’s John F. Kennedy Airport. We asked how many Euros we would get for $300 and how much of that $300 would go to fees. When information was unclear or unavailable, we contacted another branch to confirm.
Was this article helpful?