Comprehensive vs Collision Insurance Overview
Collision coverage helps pay for damage to your own vehicle due to a collision with another car or object. Comprehensive insurance is a separate type of coverage from collision insurance that protects your car from things like falling objects, theft, and vandalism. Collision and comprehensive insurance are often combined to protect a vehicle against most forms of damage, as part of so-called “full coverage.”
Key Things to Know About Comprehensive and Collision Insurance
- Comprehensive insurance covers damage to your car caused by something other than a collision, such as a fire, natural disaster, falling object or vandalism.
- Collision insurance covers repairs to your own car when you hit another vehicle, an object like a tree or fence, or a road hazard like a guardrail.
- Neither comprehensive nor collision insurance covers damage to someone else’s vehicle.
- The cost of comprehensive and collision insurance is determined largely by the value of your car.
Comprehensive vs. Collision Insurance: Similarities and Differences
Although drivers will make collision and comprehensive insurance claims under different circumstances, these two types of coverage are otherwise very similar. Let’s review the main similarities and differences.
Similarities Between Comprehensive and Collision Insurance
- Both comprehensive and collision insurance cover damage to your own vehicle. Unlike most types of insurance that are required by state law, collision and comprehensive can be used if your own vehicle is damaged.
- You don’t have to choose a coverage limit. The coverage limit is the actual cash value of your car.
- Comprehensive and collision insurance both require you to pay a deductible when you file a claim. You’ll select your deductible amount when you purchase your policy.
- Insurance companies typically offer comprehensive and collision packaged together. Some insurers require the purchase of comprehensive coverage before you can buy collision coverage, but not vice versa.
- Both are optional under state laws. If your car is financed or leased, however, your lender or leasing company will likely require you to purchase both types of coverage.
Differences Between Comprehensive and Collision Insurance
- Collision and comprehensive insurance cover different situations. Collision insurance covers drivers when they are in an accident with another vehicle or they hit an object. On the other hand, comprehensive insurance applies when a car is damaged by something other than a collision.
- Collision coverage is more expensive than comprehensive coverage. Collision insurance premiums are up to three times higher than comprehensive premiums.
What Do Comprehensive and Collision Insurance Cover?
|Cause of Damage||Comprehensive||Collision|
|Falling objects||Covered||Not Covered|
|Natural disaster||Covered||Not Covered|
|Collision with another vehicle||Not Covered||Covered|
|Collision with a stationary object||Not Covered||Covered|
|Single-car accident||Not Covered||Covered|
Neither comprehensive nor collision will cover damage to other people’s vehicles. Additionally, collision and comprehensive do not cover medical expenses of any kind.
In an accident, the at-fault driver’s liability insurance covers the victim’s injuries and property damage. The at-fault driver must use their own health insurance, personal injury protection, or MedPay to cover their own medical expenses.
In order to get a better handle on what comprehensive and collision insurance cover, let’s consider two examples:
Scenario 1 - Collision Coverage
Imagine you are driving along a rural road, and you see a deer warning sign. Sure enough, a deer darts out and hits your car.
Because the collision was not caused by a driver’s action, the damage to your car will be covered by a comprehensive policy.
Scenario 2 - Comprehensive Coverage
Now, picture that same road and that same deer, only this time the deer escapes and instead causes an accident between two cars.
In this example, the car in front of you slams on its brakes to avoid the deer, but you are following too closely to stop in time, and you rear-end the other car. Collision coverage will likely pay to repair your car in this case.
How Much Will Comprehensive and Collision Insurance Cost?
A major factor in the price of both comprehensive and collision coverage is the value of your car. The more your insurer might have to pay if your car is totaled, the more risk the insurer has and, therefore, the more you will pay in premiums.
The table below breaks down examples of auto insurance premiums for three different cars. The sample policies include liability insurance, comprehensive coverage and collision coverage.
Cost of Comprehensive Coverage vs Collision Coverage
|Vehicle Value||Comprehensive Monthly Premium||Collision Monthly Premium|
Note: Premium figures assume comprehensive and collision coverage each with a $1,000 deductible, a bodily injury liability policy with a limit of $50,000 per injured person and a maximum payout of $100,000 per accident, as well as a property damage liability limit of $50,000.
Factors to Consider Before Buying Comprehensive and Collision Insurance
Your financial situation
If your car is suddenly damaged or totaled, could you afford to repair or replace it? If the answer is no, you should get collision and comprehensive coverage to avoid a financial disaster.
The value of your car
A good rule of thumb is that if the cost of comprehensive or collision coverage exceeds 10% of your vehicle’s value, you should consider dropping them. After all, if your car is totaled, collision and comprehensive coverage will only pay you the amount that it’s worth at the time of the damage.
Your driving habits
Do you have a long commute every day, or do you only use your car occasionally? The more you drive, the higher risk you are for being in an accident, which means you’re more likely to need collision insurance.