Cheapest Car Insurance in New York

The average cost of car insurance in New York is 43% lower than the national average auto insurance premium. There are several factors that affect how much you'll pay for car insurance in New York, including your driving record, age and location, the amount of coverage you purchase, and the insurance company you buy it from.

Average Cost of Car Insurance in New York by Category

• After an at-fault accident: $456 per month      
• Driver with poor credit: $323 per month
• Teen driver: $475 per month      
• After a DUI: $241 per month          

Average Cost of Car Insurance in New York by Company

Note: Rates are an approximation based on a 45-year-old man in New York with a clean driving record. Actual rates will vary.

Average Cost of Car Insurance in New York by Age

Note: Rates are an approximation based on a driver in New York with minimum coverage and a clean driving record. Actual rates will vary.

How to Lower the Cost of Car Insurance in New York

1. Shop around and compare quotes. We recommend comparing quotes from at least three different insurance companies to make sure you are getting the best rate.
2. Choose a higher deductible. Your deductible is the amount you have to pay out of pocket before your insurance kicks in. Choosing a higher deductible can lower your premiums but means you will have to pay more out-of-pocket when you file a claim.
3. Consider lowering your coverage. Consider purchasing only the minimum amount of coverage required by your state, rather than purchasing higher limits or a full coverage policy.
4. Look for discounts you may be eligible for. For instance, most insurance companies offer a good-driver discount for customers with a clean driving record, a good-student discount, or a discount for paying your premiums in full up front.

To learn more, check out our guide to how much car insurance you need in New York as well as our picks for the cheapest car insurance companies in New York.

Drivers in New York can find cheap car insurance with “no deposit” or “no down payment,” but all that really means is you only have to pay the first month's premium to get coverage. You cannot get car insurance in New York without paying something upfront. But you can minimize the cost of coverage in New York, which ranks 50 for the cheapest car insurance rates in the country. The average monthly premium in New York is about $378 per month for full coverage and around $143 per month for state minimum coverage. Drivers in New York should expect to pay about that much in advance each month to keep their car insurance policy active.

The biggest drawback of paying for auto insurance monthly is that it's almost always more expensive than paying in full for six or 12 months of coverage upfront. Some New York insurance companies charge slightly more for month-to-month premiums, and there can also be payment processing fees. Most car insurance companies also discount rates for customers who pay in advance.

You can still find cheap car insurance options if you can't afford a big deposit, though. The best no-down-payment car insurance keeps rates low and only requires the first month's payment to start your policy.

The city in New York with the least expensive auto insurance premiums is Ithaca, which has an average premium of $1,295 per year. By comparison, the average cost of car insurance in New York overall is $3,052 per year.

Cheapest Cities for Car Insurance in New York

1. Ithaca: $1,295 per year
2. Rochester: $1,497 per year
3. Troy: $1,564 per year
4. Schenectady: $1,577 per year

Some cities in New York have cheaper car insurance premiums than others because insurance companies take a driver's ZIP code into account when calculating their premium, alongside other factors. For example, drivers who live in dense urban areas typically pay more for coverage than drivers in rural areas because they're more likely to get into an accident. And if an area has a particularly high theft rate, car insurance may be more expensive due to the risk of vehicles being stolen.

To learn more, check out WalletHub's guide to the cheapest car insurance in New York.

You can get car insurance discounts in New York based on how you drive, the car you own, and your relationship with your insurance company. In New York, car insurance companies are allowed to consider factors like marital and residential status when setting premiums. That means there are also discounts available for being married or owning a home. In New York, insurance companies cannot use your education or occupation to determine rates. That means you can't get discounts for being affiliated with certain employers or educational institutions.

Almost anyone can get a discount on car insurance in New York because most insurance companies make it easy to qualify for a variety of savings. New York insurers typically offer discounts that fall into one of three categories—policy discounts, driver discounts, and vehicle discounts.

Policy discounts typically reward customer behavior that is desirable to the insurance company. For example, most New York drivers can save by registering for paperless billing or getting both home and auto policies from the same company. Driver discounts are available to New York residents who are lower-risk to insure, like those with clean driving records. And vehicle discounts help drivers save if their car has certain safety features or anti-theft systems.

Car Insurance Discounts in New York

Remember, discounts vary among different insurance companies, so it's always best to contact the provider directly to determine which discounts you qualify for.

Progressive is the cheapest insurance for drivers who have committed SR-22-type violations in New York. New York is one of eight states that do not require high-risk drivers to file an SR-22 form as proof of insurance, but coverage can still be a lot more expensive than average for drivers who would need an SR-22 elsewhere.

For example, drivers in New York can expect to pay an average of 68% more for car insurance after actions like DUI, driving with a suspended license or reckless driving.

Cheap Insurance Companies in New York for High-Risk Drivers

Note: Premiums are for a 45-year-old driver in New York; individual premiums will vary.

Fortunately, the increase in premiums after a high-risk offense is only temporary. If you practice safe driving habits moving forward, you should see your premiums begin to go down. 

To learn more, check out WalletHub's guides to SR-22 insurance and the cheapest car insurance companies.

Best High-Risk Auto Insurance Companies in New York

Note: Rates are an approximation based on the cheapest three companies in New York for a high-risk driver. Actual rates will vary.

High-risk auto insurance in New York costs an average of $5,210 per year and is typically for drivers with major violations, such as a DUI, on their driving record. High-risk drivers face higher rates because they are likely to cost insurers more than an average driver.

Exactly how much high-risk drivers in New York pay for auto insurance depends in part on why they are classified as high-risk. For instance, a driver with a DUI will pay more for auto insurance than a driver who received a speeding ticket for going 20 mph above the speed limit.

How Your Driving History Affects Your Premiums in New York

Note: Rates are an approximation based on a driver in New York with minimum coverage. Actual rates will vary.

Tips for Finding Affordable High-Risk Car Insurance in New York

• Comparison-shop. The best way to get affordable car insurance is to compare rates from at least three insurance companies. In New York, the average high-risk driver could pay anywhere from $1,497 to $8,104 for a policy, depending on their choice of insurer. That means drivers could save around $6,607 simply by comparing quotes. At a minimum, it's a good idea to comparison-shop for insurance three and five years after a traffic violation, so you can get a lower rate when the violation falls off your record.
• Avoid filing claims. Claims can dramatically increase your premium. In New York, a collision claim raises rates by $697, on average. Before filing a claim, calculate whether the cost of the damage exceeds your deductible plus the average premium surcharge.
• Switch to a practical car or go car-free. Some vehicles are more expensive to insure than others. Your car's make, model, year, safety features, and price tag all impact how much you'll pay. Consider a practical vehicle that's more affordable to insure if you're already high-risk. If the premium is still more than you can afford, you could switch to non-owner car insurance and go car-free for a while.
• Drive safely. The easiest way to avoid traffic violations is to obey traffic laws and drive safely. You can't undo the past, but you can make good choices now. Focus on keeping a clean driving record and consider a driver safety course to potentially lower your premiums right away.

Last-Resort Options for High-Risk Drivers in New York

If you've been denied coverage from traditional insurers, look into New York's assigned risk program. With assigned risk insurance, drivers who cannot get accepted normally are assigned to insurance companies that collectively pool together to take the risk of insuring them. It's a last resort, and you'll have to prove that you've tried and failed to get insurance multiple times to qualify.

In the end, the need for high-risk car insurance is a temporary situation. Serious violations like DUIs are on your record for 15 years in New York, but most violations fall off your record within three to five years. No matter how long it takes, your high-risk status will eventually change with time if you can prove you're a safe and responsible driver again.

The best car insurance in New York for drivers with a DUI is from Progressive, American Family, and USAA. Getting a DUI in New York will raise insurance premiums by an average of $1,169 per year, but drivers can minimize the cost of post-DUI car insurance by comparing quotes from the cheapest companies.

Best DUI Insurance in New York

• Progressive: $913 per year
• American Family: $1,149 per year
• USAA: $1,309 per year
• NYCM Insurance: $1,557 per year
• State Farm: $1,765 per year

Insurance for drivers with a DUI is expensive because the violation indicates that you are more likely to file a claim than the average driver. In New York, a DUI will only affect your rate for about 3-5 years, so the higher rates won't last forever. 

Car insurance in New York is expensive because it's a no-fault state with a high rate of insurance fraud. In New York, you can expect to pay around $7,502 per year for full coverage car insurance, compared to the national average of $2,117 per year. Car insurance in New York is more expensive than the national average, which is around $2,117 per year for full coverage and about $671 per year for minimum coverage.

The cost of car insurance is steadily increasing, too, both in New York and nationwide. As the cost of providing insurance goes up, the premiums insurers charge also rise. All insured drivers share the increasing cost of insurance. That is why your rates tend to go up every time your policy is renewed, regardless of whether any individual factors—like your driving record or location—have changed.

There are several unique reasons why car insurance goes up every year in New York, too, even if your details remain the same.

Top Reasons Car Insurance Is Expensive in New York

• People in New York are driving more. As a result, the number of accidents, claims, and payouts is rising, too. For example, there were approximately 963 fatal crashes in 2020 in New York, versus 980 fatal crashes in 2014.
• Auto repairs are getting more expensive. Vehicles today cost more to repair due to the added technology and features. For example, a National Association of Insurance Commissioners study found that the average cost of vehicle repairs was around 8% higher in 2018 than it was in 2014.
• People in New York drive uninsured. As the cost of car insurance continues to rise, more drivers take the risk of driving without car insurance. In 2019, 4% of drivers lacked even minimum liability insurance in New York. The cost of uninsured drivers is passed on to consumers through higher premiums.
• Healthcare in New York is getting more expensive. Car insurance companies are hit hardest when paying out claims involving medical bills, and it's not getting any cheaper. Healthcare spending increases by an average of 5.4% every year in New York.
• New York is experiencing more severe weather. In New York, weather events like severe storms, serious winter weather, and tropical cyclones are becoming increasingly common. These weather events cause insurers to pay out a higher number of claims, which tend to be more expensive and less predictable. As a result, they have to raise rates to keep pace.

However, there could be other issues elevating your rates.

If your driving record is clean and your rates are still high, your car insurance might be expensive because of your:

Age. Drivers under 25 and older than 65 pay more for auto coverage because they are statistically more likely to be involved in serious and fatal accidents. In New York, 16-year-old drivers pay an average of $5,701 per year, 25-year-old drivers pay an average of $1,983 per year, and people over 65 pay an average of $1,768 per year.

Location and driving patterns. Population-dense cities have higher premiums than rural areas because city living usually means more accidents, more property crime, and more frequent claims. In New York, the most expensive locations for insurance are Far Rockaway, Queens Village, and New York. You can also expect rates to change based on your driving patterns—long commutes or regular driving in high-risk areas can cost you.

Financial responsibility. In New York, drivers with no credit pay 1389% more on their premiums than drivers with excellent credit. You can also demonstrate financial responsibility by maintaining minimum car insurance with no gaps in coverage. Letting your coverage lapse could result in a higher rate when you get your next policy.

Claims history. Numerous recent claims can drive up your premiums. That's one reason why it sometimes makes sense to pay out of pocket rather than file a claim, especially if a claim won't get you much more than your deductible.

How to Get Cheaper Car Insurance in New York

Multiple factors affect the cost of car insurance. Some things you can't control, but you do have a say in most of the contributing factors. Driving safely, obeying traffic laws, and keeping a clean driving record are the best ways to keep your insurance costs down.

Other than that, the best way to lower your car insurance costs is to compare rates from at least three insurance companies. Ideally, you should check your rates every 6-12 months, when you renew your policy. But at a minimum, be sure to check your record and shop for rates every three to five years, since you may be able to get a lower rate if a traffic violation falls off your record.

In New York, the most expensive policies cost roughly $13,680 per year, and the least expensive coverage costs around $1,498 per year, when all driver profile information is the same. That means you could save as much as $12,183 simply by shopping around. Be sure to confirm you're getting all the discounts you're eligible for, too.

Drivers in New York need $25,000 of bodily injury liability insurance per person (up to $50,000 per accident) and $10,000 of property damage liability insurance. New York also requires personal injury protection (PIP) and uninsured motorist insurance. PIP covers medical expenses for you and your passengers after an accident, and UM replaces the liability coverage an at-fault driver should've had and pays for your costs up to your policy limits.

Here's How Much Car Insurance Drivers Need in New York:

If you lease or finance your car, you may be required to carry coverage types that are not mandatory under New York law. Lenders usually require comprehensive and collision insurance. Collision insurance covers repairs to your car when you hit another car or object. If the damage to your vehicle was caused by something other than a collision—like a natural disaster, vandalism, falling objects, or animals—it is most likely covered by comprehensive insurance. Lenders may also require gap insurance, which covers the difference between what you owe on your loan or lease and what the vehicle was worth if it gets stolen or totaled.

Even if you're not required to carry these optional coverage types, you may still need them. You can learn more about when to drop optional coverage and the penalties for driving without insurance in New York to make sure you're paying for the coverage you need.

The cheapest states for car insurance are Iowa, Vermont and Nebraska, according to WalletHub's Cheap Car Insurance Study. They are the cheapest states for auto insurance in large part because they have low population density and relatively few uninsured motorists. In contrast, New York, Florida and New Jersey are the most expensive states for car insurance.

Population and uninsured motorists are the two main reasons for variations in policy costs from state to state. After all, fewer people means fewer drivers on the road, which means fewer accidents. And a low percentage of uninsured motorists means that more of the people on the road are responsible drivers. It also means insurance companies face fewer claims from their own customers who've been hit by uninsured motorists. Both a low population and low numbers of uninsured motorists keep claims and premiums down.

10 Cheapest States for Car Insurance:

1. Iowa
2. Vermont
3. Nebraska
4. Wyoming
5. South Dakota
6. Montana
7. New Hampshire
8. West Virginia
9. North Dakota
10. Maine

In addition to the population and number of uninsured drivers, other factors that affect car insurance costs include state laws, crime rates, and special weather hazards. State laws govern how much insurance coverage drivers are required to carry, and no-fault laws impact insurers' risks. Crime rates mainly impact comprehensive coverage, which covers losses due to theft or violence. Weather hazards - like hurricanes, hail or snowstorms - cause more breakdowns and accidents.